My Best Friend’s Daughter

Unlock Every Secret Path and Choice in This Thrilling Adventure

Ever stumbled into a game that hooks you with forbidden thrills and clever choices? ‘My Best Friend’s Daughter’ is that addictive visual novel where every decision shapes steamy encounters with characters like Natali, Elle, and Lex. I remember my first playthrough—bumping into Natali ‘accidentally’ sparked a desire meter that led to wild scenes I couldn’t unlock otherwise. This guide dives deep into strategies, day-by-day walkthroughs, and insider tips to conquer all paths. Whether you’re chasing Tom’s big moments or exploring family dynamics, get ready to master this choice-based story and uncover every hidden interaction.

Mastering Choices in My Best Friend’s Daughter

Alright, let’s get real for a second. My first playthrough of My Best Friend’s Daughter was a mess of missed opportunities and “what could have been” moments. 😅 I played it safe, tried to be the nice guy, and ended up with a seriously underwhelming ending. It wasn’t until my buddy, who inspired a whole scene in the game (more on that later), watched me play and yelled, “Dude, you have to bump her!” that everything changed. That one simple, seemingly accidental choice opened up a whole new world of interactions and drastically altered Natali’s desire meter. It was the key to the entire Natali path walkthrough.

This chapter is about saving you from that same frustration. We’re diving deep into the pivotal moments, the hidden triggers, and the optimal choices that separate a basic playthrough from an unforgettable one. Whether you’re aiming for a specific connection or want to see all the My Best Friend’s Daughter extras, understanding these decision points is everything. Let’s master these My Best Friend’s Daughter choices together.

What Happens on Day 4 with Natali?

Thursday, Day 4, is arguably the most important day in the early game. This is where you set the trajectory for your relationship with Natali. You’ll have a conversation where she opens up about her insecurities, and you’re presented with two dialogue options: talking about Lex or discussing her weight loss.

💡 Pro Tip: Always, always choose to talk about Lex. This taps into her fantasies and rebellious side, directly fueling her desire stat. The weight loss conversation is nice, but it’s the friendly path. We’re not here to just be friends, right?

Now, for the iconic moment. After the chat, you get the choice to ‘accidentally’ bump into her or don’t. This isn’t just a minor flirtation; it’s a major fork in the road.

On my first playthrough, I chickened out. I thought, “Nah, that’s too forward.” Big mistake. 🚫 Choosing not to bump her keeps things mild. She’ll be polite, but the spark isn’t really lit.

Choosing to bump into her, however? Game-changer. 🙌
This “accidental” contact sends her desire soaring. The game shows her later lying in bed, actively thinking about you (Tom), comparing you to Lex in her mind. It creates a tension and attraction that becomes the foundation for every Natali scene that follows. It’s the single most important action for any Natali path walkthrough. Skipping it makes unlocking her advanced content later a real struggle.

But Day 4 isn’t just about Natali. You also have a critical Tom Elle interaction with her daughter, Elle. She’ll ask you to fix her phone. Here, you have another defining choice:

• Fix the phone properly: This is the trust-building option. Elle sees you as helpful and reliable. It’s essential for a positive, longer-term relationship with her.
• Look through her pictures: This reduces her trust in you significantly, but it has a silver lining—it immediately unlocks a specific scene with Elle. It’s a shortcut for content, but it burns a bridge for future trust-based interactions.

Think of it this way: fixing the phone is an investment in future Tom Elle interactions, while snooping is a short-term gain with long-term consequences.

To make these Day 4 optimal choices crystal clear, here’s a breakdown:

Optimal Paths for Tom and Elle Interactions

Your relationship with Elle is a separate but parallel thread to the main Natali path. Managing this dynamic is crucial because it affects the household atmosphere and can lock or unlock certain events.

The golden rule for Tom Elle interactions is consistency. Elle is perceptive. If you’re trying to build a trusting, almost guardian-like bond with her, you need to choose the supportive options. This means:

• Helping her sincerely (like fixing the phone properly).
• Engaging in her interests when you can.
• Being a source of advice rather than another problematic adult.

Why does this matter? Because high trust with Elle can lead to unique dialogue options and scenes later where she might confide in you or be more accepting of your presence. It makes the story feel more natural and layered. On the other hand, the “snoop” path makes your character seem creepier and can lead to more confrontational or blocked scenes down the line.

It’s a classic “slow burn vs. quick thrill” scenario. For a primary playthrough, I highly recommend the trust path. Save the picture-snooping for a dedicated replay when you’re hunting for all the My Best Friend’s Daughter extras. 🎯

Unlocking Advanced Scenes on Day 7 and Beyond

If you aced Day 4 and have been stoking Natali’s desire, Day 7 (Sunday) is where things get seriously intense. This is the make-or-break moment for the romantic path. You’ll be presented with a very bold choice during a private moment.

This is the famous finger in ass path moment. And I’m not gonna sugarcoat it: This choice is mandatory if you want to continue the main romantic path with Natali. Choosing the bold action massively increases her desire and locks in the trajectory toward the most intimate scenes the game has to offer.

The alternative, “do nothing,” is essentially a soft rejection. It cools things down and will likely steer you toward a more passive or failed romance ending. There’s no middle ground here. The game asks you to commit, and this is your moment.

🎬 Funny Story: The dialogue in this and the Lex fantasy scenes felt eerily familiar. Turns out, the devs are friends with my old college roommate. They based Lex’s over-the-top “big talk” on this guy’s legendary, cringey stories about himself. Playing that scene for the first time, I was crying laughing. It just goes to show how personal and detailed the storytelling in this game can be!

Success here leads to the incredible payoff on Day 14 (Sunday). After two weeks of building tension, you’re given a major choice:
* Start something at home with Natali.
* Go and talk with Ellinor (Elle).

Choosing Natali is the climax of the primary path you’ve been cultivating. Choosing Elle represents a significant pivot, focusing on resolving her storyline. This is a major branch point, so save your game here!

And let’s talk about those delicious extras. One of the best My Best Friend’s Daughter extras is Natali’s dream sequence about Lex, which you can unlock under specific conditions (hint: it involves stoking those fantasies earlier on). Replaying with different My Best Friend’s Daughter choices is the only way to see everything. The game is designed for multiple playthroughs, with desire and trust meters acting as invisible gates to content.

Actionable Tips for Your Playthrough:
* Save Often: Use multiple save slots before every major choice, especially on Days 4, 7, and 14.
* Focus on One Path Per Playthrough: Trying to max everyone’s meters in one go is nearly impossible. Dedicate a run to Natali, and another to exploring Elle’s trust or mistrust paths.
* Don’t Fear Bold Choices: This game rewards risk. The “bump” and the Day 7 choice are perfect examples.
* Watch the Subtle Cues: The character’s animations and slight dialogue changes often hint at their internal desire or trust levels.

Your My Best Friend’s Daughter Choices FAQ

What if I skip the bump with Natali on Day 4?
You can still proceed, but her desire meter will start very low. You’ll need near-perfect choices later to compensate, and you will almost certainly miss the chance to unlock the finger in ass path and the hottest scenes. It’s the harder route.

How do I maximize Elle’s trust?
Always pick the helpful, big-brotherly options. Fix the phone properly, be supportive in conversations, and respect her boundaries. Avoid any sneaky or pervy actions toward her.

Is the Day 7 finger choice mandatory for the good ending?
For the main romantic “path” with Natali, yes, it is absolutely mandatory. It’s the game’s key checkpoint for that storyline. Choosing “do nothing” will close off that route. There is no way to reach the most advanced Natali scenes without it.

Can I see both the Natali and Elle Day 14 scenes in one playthrough?
No, the Day 14 choice is a definitive branch. You must pick one. To see both outcomes, you need to replay from a save made just before that choice.

What’s the fastest way to see all the extras?
Create dedicated save files at the start of Days 4 and 7. From there, you can quickly replay the key decisions—bump vs. no bump, fix vs. snoop, bold action vs. do nothing—to see how they branch out without replaying the entire early game each time.

Diving into ‘My Best Friend’s Daughter’ transformed my gaming nights with its clever choices and escalating tensions— from Natali’s budding desires to Elle’s trust-building moments and those pivotal Day 7 advances. You’ve got the roadmap now: prioritize bumps for heat, fix phones for loyalty, and never skip the bold paths. Replay with extras for dreams and deeper lore, like the hilarious real-life inspo behind Lex. Grab the walkthrough, experiment with every branch, and share your wildest unlocks in the comments—what’s your favorite steamy surprise?